Choosing the correct lures and tackle might be difficult, but fishing aficionados love trying new things. Mystery Tackle Box (MTB), a subscription service that sends a carefully chosen assortment of fishing equipment to your door each month, can help with that. But is it worth the cost? In this review, we’ll break down what you get, the pros and cons, real subscriber experiences, and how MTB compares to other fishing subscription boxes.
Introduction to Mystery Tackle Box
Mystery Tackle Box (MTB) is a monthly fishing subscription service designed for anglers who enjoy discovering new lures and tackle. MTB was started by Catch Co. with the goal of assisting women and fisherman in exploring cutting-edge fishing gear without having to deal with the trouble of separately researching and buying each item. A carefully chosen assortment of baits, lures, and terminal tackle is sent to subscribers each month, depending on their preferred fishing method and species of prey.
Subscription Options
MTB offers different tiers to fit various budgets and skill levels:
- Regular Box ($19.99/month) – Ideal for beginners or casual anglers, featuring a mix of baits and tackle.
- Pro Box ($29.99/month) – A step up, offering more premium lures and tackle for dedicated anglers.
- Elite Box ($39.99/month) – Designed for serious fishermen, including high-end gear with top-brand lures.
Customization and Target Species
Subscribers can choose from different box themes based on their preferred fishing type, such as:
🎣 Bass Fishing – Focused on largemouth and smallmouth bass lures.
🐟 Multi-Species – A mix of lures for bass, panfish, walleye, and more.
🌊 Inshore Saltwater – Tailored for redfish, snook, and other coastal species.
🛶 Trout & Panfish – Designed for finesse fishing with small lures.
Each box typically contains 5–7 items, including soft plastics, hard baits, hooks, weights, and even fishing accessories like stickers or small tools.
Who is Mystery Tackle Box For?
- Beginners – A great way to build a tackle collection and learn about different lure types.
- Experienced Anglers – Helps advanced fishermen discover new gear and techniques.
- Gift Seekers – A unique gift for the fishing enthusiast in your life.
Key Takeaway: Mystery Tackle Box is a fun and cost-effective way to discover new fishing gear. Whether you’re a beginner or a seasoned angler, MTB provides quality lures and tackle at a price that often beats retail value. However, if you prefer handpicking your gear, this surprise-based subscription might not be the best fit for you.
What’s Inside: Unboxing and Contents
Every Mystery Tackle Box includes a surprise mix of 5–7 fishing-related items tailored to your chosen fishing style. Here’s what you can typically find inside:
- Soft Plastics 🪱 – Worms, creature baits, swimbaits, and grubs for finesse and power fishing.
- Hard Baits 🎣 – Crankbaits, jerk baits, topwater lures, and lipless baits for various fishing conditions.
- Jigs & Spinnerbaits 🏹 – Chatterbaits, football jigs, and spinners for targeting bass and other species.
- Terminal Tackle ⚓ – Hooks, weights, jig heads, and other essentials.
- Fishing Accessories 🛠️ – Stickers, fishing tips, and sometimes small tools like line cutters.
Each box provides a mix of well-known and emerging brands, giving anglers the chance to try new lures and techniques without the guesswork.
Pros and Cons of Mystery Tackle Box Subscription
Pros:
✅ Great value – The total worth of items typically exceeds the subscription price.
✅ Variety of tackle – You get a mix of well-known brands and new products.
✅ Tailored selections – Options for different fishing styles and species.
✅ Discover new gear – Helps anglers try new techniques and lures.
Cons:
❌ No item selection – You can’t choose specific lures.
❌ Possible repeats – Some anglers may get similar items over time.
❌ Not all items fit your style – Some gear may not suit your local fishing conditions.
Subscriber Experiences and Reviews
One of the best ways to determine if Mystery Tackle Box is worth it is by looking at real subscriber experiences. Many anglers love the excitement of getting a surprise box each month, while others feel the selection may not always fit their fishing style.
What Subscribers Love ✅
- Exciting unboxing experience – It feels like a mini Christmas every month.
- Great value for the price – The total retail value often exceeds the subscription cost.
- Discovering new lures & brands – Helps anglers try baits they wouldn’t normally buy.
- Convenience – No need to research and shop for tackle individually.
Common Complaints ❌
- Lack of customization – You can’t pick specific baits or brands.
- Occasional duplicate items – Some anglers receive similar lures over time.
- Not all items fit every fishing style – Some lures may not work well in local waters.
What Anglers Are Saying:
- “I love the surprise aspect! I’ve discovered some of my favorite lures this way.” – Tom R.
- “Some months are amazing; others are just okay. It’s a gamble, but mostly worth it.” – Jake M.
- “Great for beginners or those who like experimenting with new tackle.” – Sarah K.
Key Takeaway: Mystery Tackle Box is a fun and valuable subscription for anglers who enjoy trying new fishing gear. While it’s not perfect for those who prefer picking their lures, most subscribers find the experience enjoyable and the savings worthwhile.
Comparison with Other Fishing Subscription Boxes
With several fishing subscription services available, how does Mystery Tackle Box (MTB) stack up against its competitors? While MTB is one of the most well-known options, other services like Lucky Tackle Box (LTB) and MONSTERBASS offer similar experiences with their unique twists.
How Mystery Tackle Box Compares
| Feature | Mystery Tackle Box | Lucky Tackle Box | MONSTERBASS |
| Price | $19.99+ | $19.99+ | $29.99+ |
| Customization | Limited | Some options | High |
| Lure Selection | Mix of brands | Similar to MTB | Premium brands |
| Best For | Beginners & Variety | Anglers who like brand variety | Advanced anglers |
Lucky Tackle Box (LTB) 🏆
- Similar pricing and format to MTB.
- Offers slightly more customization options in some boxes.
- Features a mix of name-brand and lesser-known lures.
- Less consistent availability compared to MTB.
MONSTER BASS 🦈
- More premium and species-specific lure selections.
- It has a higher price point but often includes well-known, high-end brands.
- Greater customization, with boxes tailored to your region and fishing style.
- It is aimed at more advanced anglers who want pro-level gear.
Which Box is Best for You?
- Choose MTB if you want an affordable, surprise-based box with a mix of tackle.
- Go with LTB if you prefer a little more customization but still enjoy variety.
- Opt for MONSTERBASS if you want high-end gear tailored to your region.
Key Takeaway: Mystery Tackle Box is one of the best all-around options for anglers who enjoy trying new lures at an affordable price. While MONSTERBASS offers more premium selections and LTB provides slightly more customization, MTB remains a solid choice for beginners and experienced anglers alike.
Conclusion
Without having to spend hours researching lures, Mystery Tackle Box is an enjoyable way to try out new fishing equipment. If you love surprises and experimenting with new baits, it’s a great deal. However, if you prefer full control over your tackle selection, a traditional shopping approach might be better.
FAQs
Can I choose what’s in my Mystery Tackle Box?
No, each box is a surprise, but you can select the type of fishing you prefer.
Is the Mystery Tackle Box worth the money?
Yes, in most cases, the value of the items exceeds the subscription price.
Can I terminate my membership at any time?
Yes, you can use your account settings to cancel at any moment.
Do they include name-brand fishing gear?
Yes, MTB includes well-known brands as well as up-and-coming companies.
What’s the best box for bass fishing?
The Bass MTB Elite is the best option for serious bass anglers.